When does a sale-leaseback count as a real sale under ASC 842?

Question

AcadiFi · Accepted Answer

A sale-leaseback is treated as a sale only if the transfer of the asset satisfies the revenue recognition guidance for a sale under ASC 606. In plain language, the buyer-lessor must obtain control of the asset. If the seller-lessee keeps too much control through a repurchase option or other restrictions, the transfer fails sale accounting and is treated as a financing arrangement instead.

Example: Red Oak Furnishings sells a warehouse with carrying amount of $1,200,000 for $1,450,000 and immediately leases it back for 10 years. Assume control transfers and the retained leaseback is an operating lease. Red Oak recognizes a gain, but only the portion related to the rights transferred to the buyer-lessor. If instead Red Oak retains a fixed-price repurchase option that makes control transfer fail, the company does not record a sale or gain. It keeps the warehouse on the books and records the cash received as a financial liability.

The FAR shortcut is to ask one question first: did control actually pass to the buyer? If yes, use sale-leaseback accounting. If no, use financing accounting. Once you clear that hurdle, the later journal entries make much more sense. Candidates often waste time on gain measurement before confirming whether a sale exists at all. Practice more in our CPA FAR question bank.

When does a sale-leaseback count as a real sale under ASC 842?

Master FAR with our CPA Course

Related Questions

Practice Questions