What's the difference between trailing and forward P/E, and when is each more appropriate?

Question

AcadiFi · Accepted Answer

The price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio is the most widely used relative valuation metric, but applying it correctly requires understanding its variations and limitations.

**Trailing P/E vs. Forward P/E:**

| | Trailing P/E | Forward P/E |
|---|---|---|
| **Formula** | Current Price / EPS (last 12 months) | Current Price / EPS (next 12 months forecast) |
| **Data source** | Audited financial statements | Analyst consensus estimates |
| **Advantage** | Uses actual, verifiable data | Reflects expected future performance |
| **Disadvantage** | Backward-looking, may include one-time items | Estimates may be wrong |

**Worked Example:**
Velaris Technologies trades at $82 per share.
- Last 12 months EPS: $3.28
- Consensus forward EPS estimate: $4.10

- **Trailing P/E** = $82 / $3.28 = **25.0x**
- **Forward P/E** = $82 / $4.10 = **20.0x**

The gap tells you the market expects significant earnings growth. If Velaris is trading at a 20x forward P/E while its sector average is 22x, it might look undervalued — but only if those earnings estimates are reliable.

**When to Use Each:**

1. **Use trailing P/E when:**
   - The company has stable, predictable earnings
   - You don't trust analyst forecasts (small-cap, limited coverage)
   - Comparing historical valuation ranges

2. **Use forward P/E when:**
   - The company is experiencing a significant earnings inflection (turnaround, new product cycle)
   - Analyst coverage is deep and consensus is reliable
   - You're comparing companies with different fiscal year-ends

**Handling Problem Scenarios:**

**Negative earnings:** P/E is meaningless when EPS is negative. Switch to Price/Sales or Price/Book. If Orion BioSciences is pre-revenue with -$2.15 EPS, a P/E ratio would produce a negative number with no analytical value.

**One-time charges:** Adjust for non-recurring items. Suppose Hartwell Industrial reported EPS of $1.85, but this included a $0.65/share restructuring charge. Adjusted EPS = $1.85 + $0.65 = $2.50. Using adjusted P/E ($82 / $2.50 = 32.8x) gives a cleaner picture than the reported P/E ($82 / $1.85 = 44.3x).

**Cyclical companies:** For cyclical firms like Crestview Mining, use a normalized P/E based on average earnings over a full business cycle (typically 5-10 years). A single year's EPS during a commodity boom will produce a misleadingly low P/E.

**Key Relationships:**
- High P/E generally implies high expected growth, low risk, or both
- The justified P/E from the Gordon Growth Model: P/E = Payout Ratio / (r - g)
- If Velaris has a 40% payout, 9% required return, and 5% growth: Justified P/E = 0.40 / (0.09 - 0.05) = 10.0x — well below its market P/E, suggesting possible overvaluation or higher-than-modeled growth expectations

**Exam Tip:** Always check whether a question specifies trailing or forward P/E. Using the wrong one is a common mistake that costs easy points.

Practice equity valuation problems in our CFA Level I question bank.

What's the difference between trailing and forward P/E, and when is each more appropriate?

Master Level I with our CFA Course

Related Questions

Practice Questions